Deal Makers vs. Checkbox Collectors: The Divide in SBA Lending

/

As SBA lending becomes more nuanced post-2024, understanding how lenders operate isn't just helpful, but essential. Especially now that eligibility rules have tightened, loan fees have returned, and the buyer pool is shrinking.

So what’s the difference between a lender who gets it done and one who doesn’t?

The Rise of the Checkbox Collector

Checkbox collectors are lenders who appear active in SBA on the surface, but behind the scenes, they rely heavily on rigid checklists. They’re focused on making sure every borrower fits a narrow profile before they’re willing to move forward.

In theory, structure is good. But in practice, checkbox lenders often apply blanket rules that ignore the flexibility SBA is designed to offer. For example:

  • They may require perfect credit scores or collateral, even when the SBA doesn’t

  • They decline deals based on debt-to-income ratios or cash flow snapshots, even when seller financing or standby notes could make the deal viable

  • They won’t touch complex business models, even if the borrower is experienced and well-prepared

The result is that deals stall—or never get off the ground at all. These lenders are often quick to say no, even when a workaround or creative solution exists.

Deal Makers Know the SBA Is a Toolset

Deal makers approach SBA lending very differently. They don’t treat every borrower like a box to be checked. They treat every deal like a puzzle that can be solved with the right structure.

These lenders understand the intent behind the SBA program: to help people access capital who might not qualify through conventional means. And they use every tool at their disposal to make it work:

  • Creative use of seller notes to meet equity injection requirements

  • Flexibility in how they view business history, cash flow, or ownership structure

  • Deep understanding of the SOP and how to interpret gray areas

The best deal makers don’t just say yes more often. They communicate clearly, ask better questions, and proactively help borrowers get across the finish line.

Why This Divide Matters More Than Ever

The SBA environment has shifted. Policies have changed. Underwriting standards have tightened. And lenders are taking a harder look at every deal.

In this climate, checkbox collectors are becoming more cautious. Some are stepping away from SBA lending entirely. Others are simply raising the bar internally, making it harder for borrowers to qualify, even if they technically meet SBA guidelines.

That’s why working with a deal-making lender is no longer optional. It’s the edge borrowers need to close with confidence.

Because even great deals fall apart if the lender isn’t aligned with your goals, timeline, or approach.

How to Spot the Difference

If you’re a borrower or broker navigating the SBA process, here are a few red flags that point to a checkbox collector:

  • “We need three years of tax returns, no exceptions”

  • “If there’s no collateral, we can’t proceed”

  • “The business has to be at least two years old”

  • “You don’t qualify due to credit score”

These are policies, not SBA rules. A dealmaker will explain options and guide you through creative solutions. A checkbox collector will move on to the next file.

Partner With People Who Know How to Get It Done

At Rapid Business Plans, we see this divide every day. Some lenders are still just collecting documents. 

The ones we work with? They’re building real relationships and closing smart, sustainable deals.

We’ve supported hundreds of SBA buyers, brokers, and lenders by creating lender-ready business plans that cut through noise and fast-track approvals. We don’t just help package deals, we help make them possible.

Ready to connect with lenders who actually want to fund your deal?